Updated Nov 16, 2026· 6 min read

Key takeaways

  • Trusting a green “Good” label alone. The Google data summarized by Wikipedia shows many failing drives gave no SMART warning.
  • Panicking over one reallocated sector. Backblaze notes timing and clustering of errors matter. A single stable value differs from a count that climbs.
  • Running repairs on a failing drive before backup. Heavy scans add stress.
  • Ignoring the cable. CRC errors are often cabling rather than the drive.
  • Treating SSD and hard drive attributes the same. SSDs report wear and spare-capacity attributes that differ, so read the tool’s guidance for the drive type.
  • Opening the drive. Never do this, and never open a power supply when checking connections.

If a hard drive’s SMART status reports failing, or key attributes such as reallocated sectors, pending sectors or uncorrectable errors are above zero and rising, back up immediately and plan to replace the drive; a passing SMART status, however, does not guarantee a healthy drive.

Read This First

SMART (Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology) is a monitoring system built into hard drives and SSDs. A tool such as the drive maker’s own utility, or a general disk-health program, reads the drive’s attributes and shows an overall verdict such as OK, Caution or Bad. The overall verdict is only one view. The raw attribute values often tell the story earlier, and different tools label thresholds differently, so interpret them carefully and follow the maker’s guidance on warranty.

How Reliable Is SMART at Predicting Failure?

Partly. Backblaze reports that it tracks five attributes (5, 187, 188, 197 and 198), and that a large majority of failed drives, around 77 percent in its data, had at least one of them above zero, while only a few percent of working drives did. It also states that roughly 23 percent of failed drives showed none of the five, so SMART misses some failures. Wikipedia’s SMART article summarizes a Google study of over 100,000 drives, reporting that about 36 percent of failed drives showed no SMART errors at all, and that drives with offline uncorrectable errors were far more likely to fail within about two months. The lesson: warning attributes are meaningful, but silence is not proof of health.

The Attributes That Matter Most

Attribute (ID) What it counts Why it matters Reaction
Reallocated Sectors Count (5) Bad sectors that the drive remapped to spares A growing count suggests progressive surface deterioration Back up; watch whether it rises
Current Pending Sector Count (197) Unstable sectors waiting to be remapped Data in those sectors may become unreadable Back up now
Offline Uncorrectable (198) Sectors that could not be corrected Strongly linked to later failure in the Google study Back up and replace
Reported Uncorrectable Errors (187) Errors the drive could not fix One of Backblaze’s tracked five Back up and replace
Command Timeout (188) Commands that timed out Can reflect drive or power and cable trouble Check cables, then monitor
Spin Retry Count (10) Failed attempts to reach spin speed Points to a mechanical or power problem Check power; replace if it persists
UltraDMA CRC Error Count (199) Transfer errors over the data link Usually cabling or port, not the platters Replace the cable, recheck

Attribute numbers and naming differ somewhat between makers, and raw values are often vendor-specific. Do not compare a raw number from one brand with another’s; look at whether it changes over time.

Step-by-Step Response

  1. Back up first. Copy irreplaceable files to another drive before running anything that stresses the disk.
  2. Record the attributes. Screenshot the SMART table, so you can compare in a few days.
  3. Rule out cabling. With the PC off and unplugged, reseat or swap the SATA data cable. A rising CRC count often stops after a cable change.
  4. Run the maker’s diagnostic. Most large drive makers publish a utility with a quick and an extended test. Follow its instructions, and a pass or fail code is usually what warranty support asks for.
  5. Decide. If sector counts are rising, or the diagnostic fails, retire the drive. If everything is stable at zero, keep monitoring.
  6. Use warranty. If the drive is covered, the maker’s process will tell you what evidence they need.

Symptom Guide

What you see Likely meaning Next step
Tool says “Caution” with a few reallocated sectors that do not change Early wear, may be stable Back up, recheck weekly
Pending sectors rising Active read trouble Back up and plan replacement
Tool says “Bad” or failing A threshold was crossed Replace; do not trust new data to it
Freezes and slow file access, SMART looks fine Could be cable, port, or the drive; SMART can miss problems Test with another cable and port; run maker diagnostics
Clicking or grinding Mechanical fault Power down, back up if possible, consider recovery service
Only CRC errors Interface problem Replace cable and recheck

Common Mistakes

  • Trusting a green “Good” label alone. The Google data summarized by Wikipedia shows many failing drives gave no SMART warning.
  • Panicking over one reallocated sector. Backblaze notes timing and clustering of errors matter. A single stable value differs from a count that climbs.
  • Running repairs on a failing drive before backup. Heavy scans add stress.
  • Ignoring the cable. CRC errors are often cabling rather than the drive.
  • Treating SSD and hard drive attributes the same. SSDs report wear and spare-capacity attributes that differ, so read the tool’s guidance for the drive type.
  • Opening the drive. Never do this, and never open a power supply when checking connections.

For Gaming PCs Specifically

Game libraries can be downloaded again, so a failing drive is mostly a time cost. The data worth protecting is save files, mod configurations, screenshots and any work files stored on the same disk. Keep those synced or copied elsewhere, and treat any hard drive that shows rising pending or uncorrectable counts as due for replacement. If the drive is your boot disk, plan replacement soon, because system instability may begin before it fails outright.

Reading Raw Values Without Confusion

Each SMART attribute has a normalized value, a worst value, a threshold and a raw value. The normalized number usually starts high and counts down toward the threshold, and the status flips to failing only when it crosses it. Raw values are the actual counts, but their format is vendor-specific, so a large-looking number is not automatically worse than a small one on a different brand. Because makers set thresholds conservatively, many drives are already in trouble well before the status changes. Focus on direction: a number that stays the same for weeks is less worrying than one that climbs between checks. Keep your screenshots dated so the trend is visible.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a SMART failure message mean?

It means the drive or your system’s monitoring has crossed a failure threshold, or a diagnostic reported a problem. Treat it as a signal to back up immediately and replace the drive.

Can a drive fail with SMART showing OK?

Yes. Backblaze reports a minority of failures with none of its five tracked attributes raised, and Wikipedia’s summary of the Google study reports a larger share without SMART errors. SMART is helpful but not complete.

Are reallocated sectors always a death sentence?

No. Drives keep spare sectors for exactly this purpose, and a small, stable number may last a while. A rising count, or pending and uncorrectable errors, is a stronger warning, and you should still back up.

Which free tool should I use to read SMART?

Use the diagnostic from your drive’s maker where one exists, because warranty support usually accepts its results. General disk-health utilities can show the full attribute table.

Can I repair a drive that reports SMART failure?

Software cannot fix failing hardware. Remapping happens automatically, but a drive reporting failure should be replaced, with data copied first.

How often should I check SMART?

Many monitoring tools can check in the background and alert you. Checking monthly, and after any freeze or unusual noise, is a reasonable habit.

L
Liam Bennett
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.

FAQ

How Reliable Is SMART at Predicting Failure?
Partly. Backblaze reports that it tracks five attributes (5, 187, 188, 197 and 198), and that a large majority of failed drives, around 77 percent in its data, had at least one of them above zero, while only a few percent of working drives did. It also states that roughly 23 percent of failed drives showed none of the five, so SMART misses some failures. Wikipedia’s SMART article summarizes a Google study of over 100,000 drives, reporting that about 36 percent of failed drives showed no SMART errors at all, and that drives with offline uncorrectable errors were far more likely to fail within about two months. The lesson: warning attributes are meaningful, but silence is not proof of health.
What does a SMART failure message mean?
It means the drive or your system’s monitoring has crossed a failure threshold, or a diagnostic reported a problem. Treat it as a signal to back up immediately and replace the drive.
Can a drive fail with SMART showing OK?
Yes. Backblaze reports a minority of failures with none of its five tracked attributes raised, and Wikipedia’s summary of the Google study reports a larger share without SMART errors. SMART is helpful but not complete.
Are reallocated sectors always a death sentence?
No. Drives keep spare sectors for exactly this purpose, and a small, stable number may last a while. A rising count, or pending and uncorrectable errors, is a stronger warning, and you should still back up.
Which free tool should I use to read SMART?
Use the diagnostic from your drive’s maker where one exists, because warranty support usually accepts its results. General disk-health utilities can show the full attribute table.
Can I repair a drive that reports SMART failure?
Software cannot fix failing hardware. Remapping happens automatically, but a drive reporting failure should be replaced, with data copied first.
How often should I check SMART?
Many monitoring tools can check in the background and alert you. Checking monthly, and after any freeze or unusual noise, is a reasonable habit.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.

More from Amazon

Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.

Amazon Prime

Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Start a Prime free trial
Amazon Music Unlimited

Ad-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.

Try Music Unlimited free
Prime for Young Adults

A Prime membership for ages 18-24 with a trial period. Eligibility is set by Amazon.

See Prime for Young Adults
Audible

Audiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Try Audible free

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.